Sunday, September 11, 2011

What If?: Gender Divisions Were Erased

       This week in class, we split up into small groups to discuss the first chapter of Orlando. The group that I was placed in was assigned a discussion question regarding the role of clothing in gender identity and self-confidence. As we discussed the topic, I made note of how gender perhaps runs deeper than certain hormones and organs (which is about as specific as I'll get on the subject).
       This observation got me thinking: if I wore girls' clothes to school and decided that my favorite color was pink and painted my nails, would I be any less of a man? Is a woman who claims to be trapped in a man's body a man all the way up until he (she?) has a sex change? Do all (or any) gay men identify as women inside? With so many questions that had to be worked out in my head, I decided to conduct a little thought experiment. What if all physical gender divisions were erased, so that the only way that boy and girl could be defined was based on what an individual chose to be?
       Obviously, I could not actually carry out this experiment, considering that, under US insurance policies, I would have to pay for the operations out of pocket. Needless to say, the experiment remained within the confines of my severely limited knowledge of the human mind. The first thing I had to consider was if there are traits or hobbies that are directly connected to gender preference. For instance, is it really a manly thing to be good at sports? The answer is no, because there are women's sports leagues in almost every sport, and athletic ability is not limited to males only (my sister has beaten me in basketball enough times to drill this idea into my head). Although a man's body is generally larger in both height and weight, this experiment was intended to weed out the gender distinctions, so for the purpose of the experiment, the only thing that made someone a man was his choice. This meant that a heavyweight boxer who spends long hours in the gym is as much of a man as a gay person with skinny jeans and a Mr. Whipple earring (don't tell him I said that) who happens to identify as a man.
       So how exactly does clothing play into all of this talk about gender? And what is the exact role of clothing anyways? In today's society, a person's clothing is chiefly used to express opinions (on a side note, my favorite shirt has the words, "Real Friends Don't Let Friends Be Cubs Fans," in bold). But we also divide clothes into girls and boys clothes. In fact, the barriers between the two have become so strong that a teenage boy won't wear a shirt that even looks like it is for girls out of fear of being teased about being gay. If you have ever seen the show "Glee", you can tell right away that Kurt is the gay character without really knowing much about the show simply because of the way he talks and what he wears.
       The root of the question is, is it our clothes that help define us as boys or girls, or is it who we are that defines us, with clothes being merely an indicator of a decision that we have already made as opposed to the cause of the decision. The answer to this question is simple: we pick our clothes, and they don't pick us (if they could, I think my sweaty gym clothes would sneak out of my locker and get as far away from me as they could). Our clothes do not change who we are; they only reflect the choices that we have made to express ourselves.
       The biggest question that was raised in this experiment was, if choice is truly the only thing that separates a man from a woman, would it truly matter what gender a person is? With all due respect to one of my heroes, Albus Dumbledore, I believe he may have been wrong about one thing. He once said to Harry Potter that it is not who we are that determines what House we are sorted in. It is our choices. However, in this case, that mantra might not apply. If you could decide to be either man or woman no matter how you dressed or acted or thought or behaved, then why does the label that you give yourself matter? Perhaps this is the chilling conclusion of the experiment: if there were no societal pressures to behave in the way that your gender is "supposed" to behave, then gender would simply become an unnecessary, outdated concept.
       In this case, perhaps I have been looking at this experiment all wrong. Maybe by trying to separate gender from clothes and personalities, I removed the very things that make gender what it is. If gender truly is a reflection of how we act in general, then many of us may be a certain gender and not even know it. Does this mean that the five year old who plays with dolls instead of trucks is a girl? I don't have answers to all of these questions, so the simplest way to figure all of this out might just be to take things at face value. If you are physically a man, then you are male, but if a man should one day realize or conclude that he identifies himself as a female, then that, too, is what he is.
       To conclude, gender is not an individual trait that is independent from things like sexual orientation, but rather the product of many qualities of a person that, combined, point one way or another. If, as a reader, you believe otherwise or would like to enhance my thought experiment, feel free to comment on this post. Thank you for reading, and GO BEARS!

No comments:

Post a Comment