Wednesday, October 19, 2011

An Inconvenient Truth: Determinism

       To be honest, Mr. Allen, I was inspired to write this blog by your example title for the Inconvenient Truth prompt. For those of you who don't believe in reading prompts, the title was, "An Inconvenient Truth: Free Will Does Not Exist." This reminded me of a concept that I learned in my chemistry called determinism. Ever since my teacher described it and its relationship with quantum theory, I have been hooked. I did extensive research on it, but I am still unsettled by its suggestions about free will and the universe.
       Essentially, determinism is a cross between a philosophy and a science- a "pseudoscience," if you will. It is the theory that, given certain conditions, everything that happens is the only possible outcome. In layman's terms (my favorite kind of terms), if I have certain genes with which I was born and was raised in a certain environment (which includes not only general things like parents and city, but extremely specific things like the color of my shirt on any given day), everything I do was destined to happen. If an exact replica of me was placed in the exact same environment as me, everything he would say or do would be exactly what I say or do, with no exceptions (a much deeper and more intellectual understanding of the subject can be gained by reading this: http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2008-11-04/?Page=2).
       If you read what I just typed, your reaction was probably a combination of bafflement and uneasiness (or maybe that was just the tacos you had for lunch). The theory makes sense at face value, but when you break it down, it challenges many preconceived notions about our existence that we humans have always had. The first thought that came to mind when I heard about this was, what about twins? Why aren't they exactly the same? And when I play Pokemon, why do wild Pokemon show up in a patch of grass when I play it once but when I start over and do everything the same way, they don't show up?
      While these arguments may have bothered me momentarily, I came to terms with them after realizing that they broke the rules of determinism. Under these rules, the environment must be exactly the same for determinism to apply. Twins are not exact genetic copies of one another; therefore, they are not bound to be the same person until they die. And as for Pokemon, the game was programmed so that there was a certain chance of a Pokemon appearing every time you step in wild grass. Chance, and not predetermined destiny, ruled the game.
       The next thing about determinism that irked me was its implications towards religion. According to basic Jewish theology, people have free will to choose between good and evil, and they should be held accountable for their actions. However, if one could argue that all of the evil actions that he/she has ever committed were not his/her fault because his/her genes and upbringing are responsible for determining his/her actions, how could we hold that person accountable even for committing atrocities such as murder? This question stumped me for a while, but then it hit me: by punishing people for their actions, we are altering their environments in a positive way so that they know to be good next time. So while a thief could blame his crimes on how he was raised, society still has the right to throw him in jail if they believe that being in jail would change his destiny for the better.
       It appeared the determinism had won me over; I am a perpetual whiner, and enabling a whiner by giving him a universal excuse is like giving a fat kid chocolate. But before I could go cause mischief, a thought struck me like a bolt of lightning (are these metaphors too generic?). Ironically, the chief opponent of determinism in my mind is another highly disputed pseudoscience: quantum mechanics.
       According to quantum mechanics, we cannot predict anything with complete certainty (just ask my uncle who bet on the Bears to beat the Lions last week); we can only measure the probability of it happening. Every time something happens (this is as general as it sounds), infinite parallel universes are created in which something different happened, and we can only measure the chance of our universe having one of these outcomes. For instance, there is a miniscule chance that I will come to school with no clothes on tomorrow. While it is extremely unlikely, in a parallel universe, it is happening as we speak. We can't say for certain if I will have clothes tomorrow at school, but we can assign a probability to it happening.
       These two theories clearly contradict each other. How can I have a predetermined destiny if there is always a chance that this destiny is thrown off course by chance? Is it really plausible that everything that has ever happened, from the creation of planet Earth to my writing of this blog, was the only way time could have unfolded from the beginning of the universe? Unfortunately for determinism, quantum mechanics has been backed by scientific experiments, and I am siding with its interpretation of our existence on this world. Free will is alive and well, and I will defend it for as long as I live.
       That is, until I get in trouble for not making my bed.

1 comment:

  1. This idea of predetermined fate (determinism) and free will/ chance (quantum mechanics) has crossed my mind multiple times. I have thought about and compared the aspects of these two different views both in a religious and a logical reasoning. Although I didn't know anything about quantum mechanics, the blog describes the basics ideas clearly and and the occasional side comments make the reading a lot more enjoyable. Overall, I seem to agree with the quantum mechanics and the chance theory more than the determinism theory because it gives me more of a sense of importance and control.

    ReplyDelete