I have decided that the format of the following blog will be slightly unorthodox. It will be a dialectical conversation between the red pill and the blue pill. More specifically, it is between the values of truth (red pill) and ignorance/happiness (blue pill). At the conclusion of the dialogue, I will patch up the rift between the two sides and come to a sort of universal conclusion.
BP: I open my case with a scenario about a witness to a murder. Nobody else saw it, and only the witness knows who the killer was. The killer is a very dangerous person, and he also knows that the witness saw him. Now let me ask you; if you were the witness, would you ever want to have witnessed the murder, thereby endangering your own life?
RP: I would, if only because I have a chance to put to justice a murderer who is on the loose. In the scenario you presented, you falsely assume that the murderer has complete power over you and can simply decide whether you live or die. This is never the case. You could turn him in, or enroll in the witness protection program. Similarly, taking the red pill does not immediately lead to your demise. Sure, life gets harder, but if you can defeat the machines, there is potential for an even more fulfilling existence.
BP: Your argument has a serious flaw in it. Let's say Neo takes the red pill, becomes The One, and frees the human race. Is a new, free existence on Earth without the Matrix any different from the one in the Matrix? There is nothing that truly differentiates the two. Furthermore, there would always be people who choose the blue pill regardless of the situation, so then you would have a split between reality and virtual reality.
RP: You seem to be under the false assumption that the Matrix will remain a decent place for humans to exist forever. The difference between living in the Matrix and living out of it is that, if at any given point the machines discover a new way to produce energy without using people, we simply become a potential threat to them. With the flip of a switch, we would all be shut down and die. People need to know the truth because it is the only way to have control over our fate. As it is said, it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied.
BP: Trust me, there are a fair share of quotes supporting both sides of this argument. Your idealistic view of so-called 'reality' is not supported by rational thought. Rationally, both real life and life in the Matrix are the same, and the less you know about real life, the better. We define real as what we can comprehend using our senses and electrical impulses in our brain. Even outside the Matrix, what makes life real? For all we know, there could be a second matrix controlling us. Reality is a useless term that we use to make the Matrix seem worse than it is. True, it looks bad with people curled up in pink goo and hooked up to machines, but that is arguably just as real and true as what the people in the goo are thinking. Another example of this is the Oracle. Does she really have feelings? Probably not, as she is just a computer program. But at a certain point that we have to recognize that, if she reacts in the same way as a human with feelings would, she might as well have real feelings. How can we objectively assert that other humans over whom we have no control can feel while robots cannot?
RP: You failed to address my main point about the Matrix's viability as a place to live forever. You keep bringing up how, logically, the Matrix is equivalent to reality, but pragmatically, it is not, if only for the sole reason that our fate is in the hands of others. The robots could change their mind about us at any time and decide to kill us all and shut down the Matrix. If everyone took the blue pill, what would stop them? We are slaves to the computers, and even if life as a free man is just as difficult as life as a slave, at least we live on our own terms.
Before I reach a conclusion, I would like to say that this debate opened the door to a multitude of new arguments between a variety of different sides. There is the age-old discussion of Plato's Cave and whether or not the shadows are worse than the real light. One could also connect this to our progress in technology and whether or not it is beneficial. This all narrows down to a core philosophical debate about the pros and cons of obtaining knowledge in every aspect of life, and whether or not a person completely ignorant to reality can be truly happy.
After weighing both sides of the arguments (that I made), I decided that, while there is no way to objectively define what reality is, and in ordinary cases, ignorance is in fact bliss; I believe there was a legitimate concern about the long term viability of giving in to the Matrix and allowing it full control of the human race. That is not to say I would necessarily recommend taking the red pill, but I believe that having actual control over one's fate is something that should be fought for, despite the apparent comforts of life in the Matrix. On the other hand, before we decide we are ready for the truth, we must be absolutely certain that the end goal is both achievable and worth making sacrifices for. In the case of the Matrix, unless you firmly believe that the robots do not have your best interests in mind and will eventually dispose of all humans (as the red pill stated), it is difficult to argue this case. Finding a balance to these sides is difficult to achieve, but ultimately, the decision to choose the truth or the better story (Life of Pi anyone?) is up to the individual.
Hello JLev,
ReplyDeleteI’d like to first comment on the really impressive amount of content you have in this blog. You don’t just extrapolate on a singe aspect of the conflict between the blue pill and the red pill. You allow one thought to connect to the next in an extremely genuine portrayal of how a mind works. Not only that, but you do it with style. The red pill/blue pill format struck me as a simper way to accomplish the Dialectics prompt; instead of an abstract analysis of two opposing ideas, you make the ideas tangible.
A lot of the things you wrote sparked new ideas inside my mind. First off, the blue pill said, “Let’s say Neo takes the red pill, becomes the One, and frees the human race.” But wasn’t Neo the One before he decided to swallow the red pill and enter into a war torn reality? After all, Morphius had been trying to track him down specifically. I don’t think Morphius ever had a doubt in his mind that Neo would choose a life sans bliss for the power of controlling his own fate. But if all that is true, doesn’t that mean the choice between the red and blue wasn’t even a choice at all, but rather Neo’s inevitable fate? Is being controlled okay if it works out in your favor? That may be one of the reasons why the Oracle make Neo believe he was not the chosen! If he believed he was nothing special, and he continued to fight (which he did), his commitment to the cause would be clear.
But as the blue pill said, the Oracle a computer program too. Her thoughts are not real, and neither are her feelings. If I were the red pill, I’d reply by saying, “If you were told that your feelings (love, pain, happiness, sadness) weren’t real, would you stop feelings them?”
-Julia
I disagree with the conclusion to your blog. I agree that ignorance is usually bliss, but I believe that the key exception is in cases of extreme curiosity. As the beginning of the film showed, someone who knows that something exists, but can’t figure out what that something is becomes perpetually unhappy. Neo stayed all night at his computer night after night, searching for an abstract, unknown thing and his life felt hollow to him because of this ignorance. Despite the hardships of the real world, it was where he was happiest because he enjoyed knowledge.
ReplyDeleteBut most people were perfectly happy to live their lives in the matrix. They either didn’t know that there is anything more than what they saw or didn’t have the curiosity to investigate if they did. For these people, it is far better to live in the matrix. As you stated above there is no functional difference between the matrix and the real world. There is only a risk that machines will kill everyone who becomes free.
You said that being slaves to the machines meant that we were at their mercy and that they could kill us if they felt like it. But when further analyzed, there is no impact to that kind of death. We say that death is bad because life is good, because it might be painful, because we fear it, or because death is the end of all possibilities for good, but none of these apply to death while in the matrix. You said that the fakeness of life in the matrix is bad; if that is true than what is a person really missing by dying there. A person would not feel the pain of death, if there was any, because they would still be in their matrix dream-world. We cannot fear a death that we don’t know about. And finally the only “possibility for good” that could occur sans death is escape from the matrix, but as articulated above that life is 1. a poor one and 2. a world in which death is more likely, but a death that is overall worse.