Thursday, February 9, 2012

An Inconvenient Truth: The Dichotomy of Genius

       Throughout the novel Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad, Kurtz is something of an enigma. We only learn about him through other people's testimonies about his actions, whether they feel that he was a brilliant genius, a madman who has lost perspective on his work, or some combination of the two. In fact, as a reader, it is difficult to judge him as good or bad even after having finished the book. One of the reasons for this is that Marlow, the protagonist of the story, chooses to see Kurtz for the talented agent that he was when he first started out and ignores many of the horrific atrocities that he was responsible for. This brings up the unsettling truth that even the most profound and gifted people among us can commit terrible acts of cruelty under certain strenuous circumstances.
       It is not difficult to find historical examples of smart and charismatic leaders who have a history of human rights violations. Nearly every dictator in history has used his/her cunning, smarts, and ability to raise followers through masterful oration to earn his/her power. A striking example of this is Adolf Hitler, who possessed all three of these qualities. He, much like Kurtz, was an exceptional speaker, was meticulously organized, and had strongly held beliefs that he convinced an entire population to buy into.
       Of course, we remember him now (and rightly so) as an evil dictator who started the bloodiest war of all time and committed one of the most horrific cases of genocide this world has ever seen. This is similar to how Kurtz is seen by the Company as a madman whose methods have become increasingly unsound. The reason that this bothers me is that Marlow actually paints Kurtz in a positive light on the whole. While he is no Hitler, Kurtz certainly isn't winning a Nobel Peace Prize anytime soon. He put the heads of Africans on display outside of his house as a warning; this is a blatant example of cruelty and racism in its purest form.
       This brings me to the actual root of my uneasiness about the dichotomy of genius. It's not the fact that a brilliant mind can falter and go insane, but rather the notion that we as a society tend to glamorize the intelligence of people who don't turn out to be decent human beings. We should be looking at a person's character above all else, and the fact that we don't really rubs me the wrong way.
       It was difficult to come to terms with this inconvenient truth. In my opinion, Joseph Conrad is a racist for not making Kurtz out to be the bad guy in a story in which he definitely was one. In today's world, we idolize the Steve Jobses and the Mark Zuckerbergs, the people who, using knowledge, opportunity, and a little luck, become extremely successful and wealthy. Does anyone ever stop to think, is this man a good man at heart? Steve Jobs essentially built his empire on the backs of Chinese workers, and, as we see from The Social Network, Zuckerberg was antisocial, unfriendly, and cold to his best friends as he was making his billions.
       In the end, however, being bitter about the values of our entire culture won't help me in any way, so I've decided to just worry about how I am upholding my own morals and values and being the good person that I criticized so many revered men for not being. This will help me lead by example; if I can use my intelligence, my rugged good looks, and my down-to-earth personality to succeed in life while continuing to do the right thing, others will see that you don't have to compromise who you are to make a living. As long as I continue on this path, my legacy will be much more uniformly positive than that of Kurtz, the great enigma.

PS Too big, too strong, too fast, too good. #1

No comments:

Post a Comment