When Mr. Allen told us that we were watching Once, my first reaction was, "When can we watch The Matrix???" True, I had never seen either before, but even though I knew that Once had some good music, it seemed like one of those artsy fartsy independent movies that makes you think for a while but is very forgettable. At least, I thought, we wouldn't have any real English class this week. Little did I know that Once would be anything but forgettable for me; it would haunt me for a while and lead me to one of the more radical changes of mind I would have all year.
The topic of love is one of the more prominent themes of the movie, and I felt that it had an interesting take on love. Prior to watching it, I saw love as something of a bond, an emotional and/or physical attraction between people that kept them together through thick and thin. This was very similar to the mainstream notion of love, especially in Hollywood; every potential couple in every movie that hints at a relationship becomes one. There is essentially no such thing as a boy and a girl who are best friends in a movie from start to finish without any romantic involvement in between in Hollywood. Only in the greatest movies of all time, like Titanic, do the main characters who are in love don't end up together. I felt that this was an anomaly; love between two people was meant to be shared, no matter the circumstances.
So when Once decided to ruin the Guy's and Girl's love by separating them and having them end up with people who aren't their "soulmates," I was disheartened (Side note: The untranslated Dutch that the Girl says to the Guy after she tells him she is married is roughly as follows: "It is you that I love." When I looked this up after the end of the movie, I was furious that they left each other). Why couldn't they have just not given Girl a husband? They would be together for sure! The director was telling me lies; I guess when your mind's made up, you can just leave the film the way you want it. After watching the movie, I was feeling depressed, like I was falling slowly from the high that the movie had given me. I had fallen from the sky all the way down, and even when I was trying to pull myself away, you might as well say it to me now; I was just a broken hearted Hoover fixer sucker guy (that one was a stretch, but I have been planning to do that ever since I saw the blog prompt).
On a more serious note, the power of the movie left me puzzled. Why wasn't the ending a sad one? Why did they seem so happy with other people? This raised serious questions in my mind about what love really was. If love was really the unbreakable bond that I made it out to be, were they really in love? After much deliberation, I realized that it was I who was creating these questions for myself by trying to define the Guy and Girl with broad labels such as love. Love is too broad of a word to be used to really describe the relationship between two people. The Guy and Girl weren't just in love; the bond they shared with their music really could not be compared with the bond between lovers, or between mother and child. This realization forced me to expand the word love into a multifaceted word with no real universal definition.
When I changed my mind to account for the notion that no love between two people is exactly the same, the movie was much easier to resolve in my mind. The Guy and Girl had a deep soulful connection between them through music, but due to circumstances, this relationship was fleeting. Through the relationship, Guy was able to gain the confidence to win back the heart of his ex-girlfriend; while he and Girl seemed perfect together, he was not prepared to be the new father of Girl's daughter and become fully committed. The Girl was given the gift of beautiful music with the piano and their album, but while she ultimately wanted to be with Guy, her love for her daughter, plus her obligation to her husband, kept her in Ireland. They both left each other as changed, happier people, and the intimacy that they shared was magical.
In conclusion, I absolutely loved the movie.
No comments:
Post a Comment